Porsche 911 most reliable, Citroen DS3 least reliable at the 2025 MOT
The Citroen DS3 failed its 2025 MOT 1.4 times as often as cars of the same age: 48% of tests ended in a fail, against about 34% for cars of the same age. The most reliable was the Porsche 911, which failed less than half as often as cars of the same age. The comparison covers 199 models with at least 20,000 MOT tests.

Top five
- 1Porsche 911same-age cars 24% ยท 22,908 tests5.8%
- 2Lexus RXsame-age cars 26% ยท 23,968 tests12%
- 3Audi TTsame-age cars 28% ยท 70,250 tests16%
- 4Mazda MX-5same-age cars 27% ยท 40,760 tests16%
- 5Porsche Cayennesame-age cars 24% ยท 26,247 tests12%
Bottom five
- 1Citroen DS3same-age cars 34% ยท 68,131 tests48%
- 2Renault Cliosame-age cars 27% ยท 227,245 tests40%
- 3DS Ds3same-age cars 23% ยท 33,856 tests34%
- 4Renault Meganesame-age cars 32% ยท 68,969 tests43%
- 5Citroen C4 Cactussame-age cars 20% ยท 21,184 tests30%
The top is a mix of manufacturers. 6 of the 15 most reliable models come from Japanese manufacturers.
One fault stands out among the worst. For the Citroen DS3, the most over-represented failure was transmission: 12 fails per 100 tests, 7.2 times as often as for cars in general.
The Porsche 911 and Lexus RX fail least often, the Citroen DS3 most often
The 15 best and 15 worst models. Cars aged 3โ15 (first used 2010โ2022), at least 50 tests per year. Van models are left out.
Show as table
| Model | Difference vs same age | Failure rate (raw) | Tests |
|---|---|---|---|
| Porsche 911 | โ18.3 pp | 5.8% | 22,908 |
| Lexus RX | โ13.2 pp | 12.4% | 23,968 |
| Audi TT | โ11.7 pp | 15.9% | 70,250 |
| Mazda MX-5 | โ11.5 pp | 15.7% | 40,760 |
| Porsche Cayenne | โ11.5 pp | 12.4% | 26,247 |
| Lexus CT | โ11.2 pp | 17.4% | 31,025 |
| Honda CR-V | โ9.9 pp | 17.6% | 134,235 |
| Honda Jazz | โ9.8 pp | 17.4% | 231,041 |
| Porsche Macan | โ9.8 pp | 9.3% | 34,865 |
| Mercedes-Benz SLK | โ9.5 pp | 24.2% | 25,375 |
| Lexus NX | โ8.9 pp | 9.8% | 31,659 |
| Audi A6 | โ8.9 pp | 17.8% | 102,795 |
| Land Rover Range Rover | โ8.5 pp | 17.5% | 63,964 |
| BMW 5 Series | โ8.2 pp | 17.8% | 164,510 |
| Land Rover Range Rover Sport | โ7.8 pp | 17.5% | 94,167 |
| Audi Q7 | โ7.5 pp | 15.8% | 43,539 |
| Honda HR-V | โ7.4 pp | 11.7% | 36,861 |
| BMW X5 | โ7.4 pp | 15.7% | 72,167 |
| Mini One | โ7.3 pp | 20.5% | 50,675 |
| Land Rover Freelander | โ7.3 pp | 29.3% | 60,309 |
| Audi Q5 | โ7.0 pp | 15.8% | 113,953 |
| Toyota Prius | โ6.9 pp | 18.6% | 133,936 |
| Suzuki Celerio | โ6.5 pp | 17.1% | 27,232 |
| Mini Countryman | โ6.5 pp | 15.4% | 101,624 |
| Volkswagen UP! | โ6.4 pp | 20.5% | 127,288 |
| Volkswagen Golf | โ6.3 pp | 20.0% | 667,973 |
| Toyota RAV4 | โ6.2 pp | 15.5% | 93,650 |
| Mini Cooper | โ6.1 pp | 15.8% | 239,697 |
| Audi Q2 | โ6.1 pp | 9.9% | 84,425 |
| Land Rover Defender | โ6.0 pp | 18.5% | 52,174 |
| Mini John Cooper Works | โ5.9 pp | 13.3% | 22,293 |
| Land Rover Range Rover Evoque | โ5.9 pp | 18.6% | 165,133 |
| Jaguar XF | โ5.9 pp | 24.4% | 83,706 |
| BMW X1 | โ5.8 pp | 17.6% | 111,801 |
| BMW 4 Series | โ5.7 pp | 16.5% | 111,597 |
| BMW 3 Series | โ5.5 pp | 21.0% | 346,598 |
| Audi A3 | โ5.5 pp | 20.8% | 349,479 |
| Volkswagen Touareg | โ5.5 pp | 19.7% | 29,875 |
| Volkswagen T-Roc | โ5.4 pp | 9.3% | 92,089 |
| Jaguar I-Pace | โ5.3 pp | 8.5% | 22,471 |
| BMW I3 | โ5.2 pp | 13.1% | 26,184 |
| Mercedes-Benz GLE | โ5.1 pp | 12.9% | 33,676 |
| BMW X3 | โ5.0 pp | 17.5% | 97,976 |
| Land Rover Discovery | โ4.9 pp | 19.7% | 98,344 |
| Audi A5 | โ4.9 pp | 21.9% | 116,238 |
| Audi Q3 | โ4.9 pp | 17.6% | 140,552 |
| Mini Cooper S | โ4.9 pp | 13.9% | 109,599 |
| Mercedes-Benz E-Class | โ4.9 pp | 21.4% | 198,924 |
| Skoda Citigo | โ4.9 pp | 22.1% | 52,097 |
| Seat Ateca | โ4.6 pp | 12.2% | 51,705 |
| Peugeot 108 | โ4.5 pp | 18.7% | 77,108 |
| Smart Fortwo | โ4.4 pp | 25.3% | 36,185 |
| Mercedes-Benz C-Class | โ4.3 pp | 22.4% | 291,058 |
| Toyota Auris | โ4.3 pp | 25.1% | 119,161 |
| Toyota Avensis | โ4.3 pp | 28.5% | 29,574 |
| Mazda CX-3 | โ4.3 pp | 16.5% | 25,277 |
| Mercedes-Benz GLC | โ4.2 pp | 13.7% | 84,110 |
| BMW 1 Series | โ4.1 pp | 21.9% | 343,724 |
| Ford Puma | โ4.1 pp | 8.5% | 89,711 |
| Skoda Karoq | โ4.1 pp | 11.1% | 60,668 |
| Mazda CX-30 | โ4.1 pp | 8.7% | 20,642 |
| Suzuki Vitara | โ4.1 pp | 15.0% | 70,400 |
| Skoda Yeti | โ4.1 pp | 26.1% | 74,268 |
| Volvo XC40 | โ4.0 pp | 10.0% | 88,007 |
| Toyota Aygo | โ3.9 pp | 20.7% | 230,511 |
| Toyota Yaris | โ3.9 pp | 21.3% | 328,202 |
| Volvo XC60 | โ3.9 pp | 19.5% | 115,821 |
| Volkswagen Tiguan | โ3.9 pp | 17.8% | 245,388 |
| BMW 2 Series | โ3.7 pp | 16.3% | 134,863 |
| Jaguar E | โ3.6 pp | 12.6% | 32,436 |
| Honda Civic | โ3.6 pp | 24.5% | 152,003 |
| Mercedes-Benz B-Class | โ3.5 pp | 24.4% | 59,760 |
| Jaguar XE | โ3.5 pp | 19.0% | 42,897 |
| Audi A4 | โ3.2 pp | 23.5% | 177,810 |
| Skoda Octavia | โ3.2 pp | 21.7% | 174,759 |
| Toyota Corolla | โ3.1 pp | 10.5% | 74,693 |
| Skoda Kodiaq | โ3.1 pp | 12.8% | 43,952 |
| Jaguar F-Pace | โ3.1 pp | 14.9% | 58,484 |
| Volvo XC90 | โ2.9 pp | 20.3% | 61,723 |
| Kia Stonic | โ2.9 pp | 12.3% | 32,469 |
| Mercedes-Benz GLA | โ2.8 pp | 16.7% | 91,753 |
| Volkswagen Passat | โ2.8 pp | 25.5% | 138,295 |
| Suzuki Ignis | โ2.8 pp | 14.2% | 26,235 |
| Volkswagen Sharan | โ2.7 pp | 22.0% | 31,984 |
| Volkswagen Touran | โ2.5 pp | 26.9% | 48,034 |
| Ford Kuga | โ2.4 pp | 20.1% | 302,133 |
| Toyota Verso | โ2.3 pp | 29.7% | 25,081 |
| Mini Clubman | โ2.2 pp | 20.4% | 25,982 |
| Hyundai Ioniq | โ2.2 pp | 13.1% | 57,075 |
| Volkswagen T-Cross | โ2.2 pp | 11.4% | 30,829 |
| Peugeot 107 | โ2.1 pp | 34.6% | 67,172 |
| Suzuki SX4 | โ2.1 pp | 24.4% | 35,889 |
| Volvo V60 | โ2.0 pp | 22.7% | 40,654 |
| Mitsubishi Asx | โ2.0 pp | 25.5% | 28,733 |
| Suzuki Swift | โ1.9 pp | 23.5% | 111,357 |
| Citroen C1 | โ1.9 pp | 27.6% | 132,207 |
| Land Rover Discovery Sport | โ1.9 pp | 19.0% | 110,042 |
| Ford Mondeo | โ1.9 pp | 28.2% | 121,797 |
| Toyota C-HR | โ1.7 pp | 14.1% | 102,173 |
| Mazda CX-5 | โ1.7 pp | 19.6% | 72,360 |
| Volkswagen Scirocco | โ1.7 pp | 30.5% | 39,502 |
| Skoda Kamiq | โ1.6 pp | 11.2% | 23,994 |
| Seat Alhambra | โ1.6 pp | 23.7% | 24,075 |
| Seat Leon | โ1.5 pp | 22.6% | 166,783 |
| Kia Niro | โ1.5 pp | 12.6% | 98,931 |
| Vauxhall Viva | โ1.5 pp | 21.4% | 38,090 |
| Volkswagen ID.3 | โ1.5 pp | 11.0% | 25,653 |
| BMW X2 | โ1.5 pp | 14.0% | 21,222 |
| Mercedes-Benz A-Class | โ1.4 pp | 20.0% | 338,191 |
| Skoda Fabia | โ1.4 pp | 24.8% | 179,129 |
| Ford C-Max | โ1.3 pp | 29.4% | 88,829 |
| Skoda Superb | โ1.3 pp | 22.2% | 63,225 |
| Audi A1 | โ1.2 pp | 23.8% | 234,825 |
| Hyundai i10 | โ1.2 pp | 26.0% | 227,851 |
| Hyundai Tucson | โ1.1 pp | 16.5% | 163,238 |
| Land Rover Range Rover Velar | โ1.1 pp | 15.9% | 32,146 |
| Mazda 2 | โ1.0 pp | 26.7% | 104,207 |
| Nissan Note | โ1.0 pp | 31.9% | 100,984 |
| Mitsubishi Outlander | โ0.9 pp | 22.7% | 71,994 |
| Kia Soul | โ0.9 pp | 27.9% | 22,853 |
| Vauxhall Grandland X | โ0.6 pp | 13.2% | 31,963 |
| Suzuki Alto | โ0.6 pp | 34.0% | 38,416 |
| Hyundai i20 | โ0.5 pp | 26.4% | 124,258 |
| Kia Xceed | โ0.5 pp | 12.3% | 24,594 |
| Kia Venga | โ0.3 pp | 29.0% | 46,359 |
| MG HS | โ0.2 pp | 11.9% | 30,314 |
| Citroen C3 Aircross | โ0.2 pp | 15.4% | 35,536 |
| Hyundai Kona | โ0.2 pp | 13.8% | 61,500 |
| Ford KA | +0.2 pp | 30.9% | 139,685 |
| Mazda 6 | +0.2 pp | 28.1% | 47,222 |
| Mercedes-Benz CLA | +0.3 pp | 19.3% | 75,518 |
| Kia Picanto | +0.3 pp | 25.8% | 165,534 |
| Mazda 3 | +0.3 pp | 27.1% | 83,271 |
| Skoda Rapid | +0.5 pp | 27.4% | 21,479 |
| Seat Arona | +0.5 pp | 15.8% | 56,484 |
| Kia Sportage | +0.6 pp | 22.6% | 294,022 |
| Kia Rio | +0.7 pp | 28.2% | 91,074 |
| Ford Focus | +0.9 pp | 28.6% | 692,707 |
| Vauxhall Astra | +1.0 pp | 30.7% | 443,645 |
| Kia Sorento | +1.1 pp | 25.9% | 31,088 |
| Vauxhall Meriva | +1.3 pp | 34.8% | 63,012 |
| Vauxhall Crossland | +1.3 pp | 16.4% | 62,301 |
| Nissan Leaf | +1.3 pp | 19.8% | 52,897 |
| Fiat Panda | +1.3 pp | 31.8% | 59,430 |
| Hyundai ix20 | +1.6 pp | 30.8% | 28,751 |
| Volvo V40 | +1.8 pp | 27.8% | 94,568 |
| Hyundai Santa FE | +1.8 pp | 29.8% | 28,666 |
| Volkswagen Polo | +1.9 pp | 28.3% | 502,172 |
| Vauxhall Grandland | +2.1 pp | 18.7% | 42,531 |
| Renault Captur | +2.1 pp | 24.0% | 162,092 |
| Ford B-Max | +2.3 pp | 32.1% | 53,635 |
| Ford S-Max | +2.3 pp | 32.9% | 55,308 |
| Tesla Model 3 | +2.3 pp | 15.6% | 86,639 |
| Volkswagen Beetle | +2.4 pp | 33.7% | 20,951 |
| Nissan Micra | +2.4 pp | 30.2% | 137,308 |
| Vauxhall Insignia | +2.7 pp | 32.3% | 174,355 |
| Alfa Romeo Giulietta | +2.9 pp | 34.5% | 24,485 |
| Hyundai ix35 | +3.0 pp | 36.2% | 49,770 |
| Nissan X-Trail | +3.5 pp | 27.0% | 72,495 |
| Kia Ceed | +3.5 pp | 30.0% | 110,450 |
| Smart Forfour | +3.6 pp | 26.8% | 21,160 |
| Ford Ecosport | +3.6 pp | 22.9% | 110,902 |
| Vauxhall Zafira | +3.6 pp | 35.6% | 132,650 |
| Ford Fiesta | +3.7 pp | 31.4% | 1,086,255 |
| Fiat 500 | +3.7 pp | 31.1% | 315,134 |
| MG ZS | +3.9 pp | 17.6% | 60,555 |
| Nissan Pulsar | +4.0 pp | 29.3% | 20,791 |
| Nissan Qashqai | +4.4 pp | 29.4% | 560,260 |
| Hyundai i30 | +4.6 pp | 34.0% | 91,640 |
| Nissan Juke | +4.7 pp | 30.3% | 326,524 |
| Ford Galaxy | +4.7 pp | 32.6% | 42,437 |
| Tesla Model Y | +4.7 pp | 16.2% | 32,476 |
| Fiat 500X | +4.9 pp | 27.3% | 36,657 |
| Renault Zoe | +5.1 pp | 21.4% | 26,996 |
| Jeep Renegade | +5.2 pp | 27.5% | 29,281 |
| Peugeot 3008 | +5.2 pp | 28.7% | 143,194 |
| Peugeot 208 | +5.2 pp | 29.6% | 218,868 |
| Citroen C3 | +5.3 pp | 32.4% | 160,565 |
| Peugeot 2008 | +5.4 pp | 26.0% | 144,569 |
| Ford Grand C-Max | +5.4 pp | 34.8% | 34,570 |
| Seat Ibiza | +5.5 pp | 32.3% | 169,193 |
| Peugeot 308 | +5.6 pp | 33.7% | 110,832 |
| Renault Kadjar | +5.9 pp | 26.4% | 69,279 |
| MG 3 | +5.9 pp | 25.1% | 24,672 |
| Vauxhall Corsa | +6.5 pp | 33.2% | 750,609 |
| Peugeot 5008 | +7.5 pp | 28.7% | 36,977 |
| Vauxhall Adam | +7.8 pp | 34.3% | 58,720 |
| Renault Scenic | +7.8 pp | 41.8% | 22,971 |
| Vauxhall Mokka | +7.9 pp | 30.9% | 252,616 |
| Fiat Punto | +8.2 pp | 42.9% | 29,424 |
| Dacia Duster | +9.3 pp | 29.0% | 81,404 |
| Dacia Sandero | +9.5 pp | 31.0% | 117,357 |
| Peugeot 207 | +9.9 pp | 48.7% | 57,709 |
| Citroen C4 | +10.0 pp | 38.2% | 114,334 |
| Citroen C4 Cactus | +10.2 pp | 30.2% | 21,184 |
| Renault Megane | +11.1 pp | 43.3% | 68,969 |
| DS Ds3 | +11.4 pp | 34.1% | 33,856 |
| Renault Clio | +13.0 pp | 40.2% | 227,245 |
| Citroen DS3 | +14.1 pp | 48.2% | 68,131 |
Source: DVSA anonymised MOT tests (OGL v3.0)
How we calculated this
Why adjust for age? Older cars fail far more often, so a raw failure rate would simply favour newer models. Each model is therefore compared only with cars from the same year, weighted by the number of tests.
The 15 best and 15 worst models. Cars aged 3โ15 (first used 2010โ2022), at least 50 tests per year. Van models are left out.