How rare is your car? Built on open registration data

Porsche 911 most reliable, Citroen DS3 least reliable at the 2025 MOT

The Citroen DS3 failed its 2025 MOT 1.4 times as often as cars of the same age: 48% of tests ended in a fail, against about 34% for cars of the same age. The most reliable was the Porsche 911, which failed less than half as often as cars of the same age. The comparison covers 199 models with at least 20,000 MOT tests.

RareCar ยท Published 17 Nov 2026 ยท 3 min read
Source: DVSA anonymised MOT tests (OGL v3.0)

WhatsAppFacebookX
Porsche 911
Porsche 911. Photo: Alexander-93 ยท CC BY-SA 4.0 ยท Wikimedia Commons
of Citroen DS3 tests failed
48%
same-age cars 34%
of Porsche 911 tests failed
5.8%
same-age cars 24%

Top five

  1. 1Porsche 911same-age cars 24% ยท 22,908 tests5.8%
  2. 2Lexus RXsame-age cars 26% ยท 23,968 tests12%
  3. 3Audi TTsame-age cars 28% ยท 70,250 tests16%
  4. 4Mazda MX-5same-age cars 27% ยท 40,760 tests16%
  5. 5Porsche Cayennesame-age cars 24% ยท 26,247 tests12%

Bottom five

  1. 1Citroen DS3same-age cars 34% ยท 68,131 tests48%
  2. 2Renault Cliosame-age cars 27% ยท 227,245 tests40%
  3. 3DS Ds3same-age cars 23% ยท 33,856 tests34%
  4. 4Renault Meganesame-age cars 32% ยท 68,969 tests43%
  5. 5Citroen C4 Cactussame-age cars 20% ยท 21,184 tests30%

The top is a mix of manufacturers. 6 of the 15 most reliable models come from Japanese manufacturers.

One fault stands out among the worst. For the Citroen DS3, the most over-represented failure was transmission: 12 fails per 100 tests, 7.2 times as often as for cars in general.

The Porsche 911 and Lexus RX fail least often, the Citroen DS3 most often

The 15 best and 15 worst models. Cars aged 3โ€“15 (first used 2010โ€“2022), at least 50 tests per year. Van models are left out.

โ† fails less oftenfails more often โ†’
Porsche 911 ยท 22,908 tests
โˆ’18.3 pp
Lexus RX ยท 23,968 tests
โˆ’13.2 pp
Audi TT ยท 70,250 tests
โˆ’11.7 pp
Mazda MX-5 ยท 40,760 tests
โˆ’11.5 pp
Porsche Cayenne ยท 26,247 tests
โˆ’11.5 pp
Lexus CT ยท 31,025 tests
โˆ’11.2 pp
Honda CR-V ยท 134,235 tests
โˆ’9.9 pp
Honda Jazz ยท 231,041 tests
โˆ’9.8 pp
Porsche Macan ยท 34,865 tests
โˆ’9.8 pp
Mercedes-Benz SLK ยท 25,375 tests
โˆ’9.5 pp
Lexus NX ยท 31,659 tests
โˆ’8.9 pp
Audi A6 ยท 102,795 tests
โˆ’8.9 pp
Land Rover Range Rover ยท 63,964 tests
โˆ’8.5 pp
BMW 5 Series ยท 164,510 tests
โˆ’8.2 pp
Land Rover Range Rover Sport ยท 94,167 tests
โˆ’7.8 pp
Vauxhall Corsa ยท 750,609 tests
+6.5 pp
Peugeot 5008 ยท 36,977 tests
+7.5 pp
Vauxhall Adam ยท 58,720 tests
+7.8 pp
Renault Scenic ยท 22,971 tests
+7.8 pp
Vauxhall Mokka ยท 252,616 tests
+7.9 pp
Fiat Punto ยท 29,424 tests
+8.2 pp
Dacia Duster ยท 81,404 tests
+9.3 pp
Dacia Sandero ยท 117,357 tests
+9.5 pp
Peugeot 207 ยท 57,709 tests
+9.9 pp
Citroen C4 ยท 114,334 tests
+10.0 pp
Citroen C4 Cactus ยท 21,184 tests
+10.2 pp
Renault Megane ยท 68,969 tests
+11.1 pp
DS Ds3 ยท 33,856 tests
+11.4 pp
Renault Clio ยท 227,245 tests
+13.0 pp
Citroen DS3 ยท 68,131 tests
+14.1 pp
Show as table
ModelDifference vs same ageFailure rate (raw)Tests
Porsche 911โˆ’18.3 pp5.8%22,908
Lexus RXโˆ’13.2 pp12.4%23,968
Audi TTโˆ’11.7 pp15.9%70,250
Mazda MX-5โˆ’11.5 pp15.7%40,760
Porsche Cayenneโˆ’11.5 pp12.4%26,247
Lexus CTโˆ’11.2 pp17.4%31,025
Honda CR-Vโˆ’9.9 pp17.6%134,235
Honda Jazzโˆ’9.8 pp17.4%231,041
Porsche Macanโˆ’9.8 pp9.3%34,865
Mercedes-Benz SLKโˆ’9.5 pp24.2%25,375
Lexus NXโˆ’8.9 pp9.8%31,659
Audi A6โˆ’8.9 pp17.8%102,795
Land Rover Range Roverโˆ’8.5 pp17.5%63,964
BMW 5 Seriesโˆ’8.2 pp17.8%164,510
Land Rover Range Rover Sportโˆ’7.8 pp17.5%94,167
Audi Q7โˆ’7.5 pp15.8%43,539
Honda HR-Vโˆ’7.4 pp11.7%36,861
BMW X5โˆ’7.4 pp15.7%72,167
Mini Oneโˆ’7.3 pp20.5%50,675
Land Rover Freelanderโˆ’7.3 pp29.3%60,309
Audi Q5โˆ’7.0 pp15.8%113,953
Toyota Priusโˆ’6.9 pp18.6%133,936
Suzuki Celerioโˆ’6.5 pp17.1%27,232
Mini Countrymanโˆ’6.5 pp15.4%101,624
Volkswagen UP!โˆ’6.4 pp20.5%127,288
Volkswagen Golfโˆ’6.3 pp20.0%667,973
Toyota RAV4โˆ’6.2 pp15.5%93,650
Mini Cooperโˆ’6.1 pp15.8%239,697
Audi Q2โˆ’6.1 pp9.9%84,425
Land Rover Defenderโˆ’6.0 pp18.5%52,174
Mini John Cooper Worksโˆ’5.9 pp13.3%22,293
Land Rover Range Rover Evoqueโˆ’5.9 pp18.6%165,133
Jaguar XFโˆ’5.9 pp24.4%83,706
BMW X1โˆ’5.8 pp17.6%111,801
BMW 4 Seriesโˆ’5.7 pp16.5%111,597
BMW 3 Seriesโˆ’5.5 pp21.0%346,598
Audi A3โˆ’5.5 pp20.8%349,479
Volkswagen Touaregโˆ’5.5 pp19.7%29,875
Volkswagen T-Rocโˆ’5.4 pp9.3%92,089
Jaguar I-Paceโˆ’5.3 pp8.5%22,471
BMW I3โˆ’5.2 pp13.1%26,184
Mercedes-Benz GLEโˆ’5.1 pp12.9%33,676
BMW X3โˆ’5.0 pp17.5%97,976
Land Rover Discoveryโˆ’4.9 pp19.7%98,344
Audi A5โˆ’4.9 pp21.9%116,238
Audi Q3โˆ’4.9 pp17.6%140,552
Mini Cooper Sโˆ’4.9 pp13.9%109,599
Mercedes-Benz E-Classโˆ’4.9 pp21.4%198,924
Skoda Citigoโˆ’4.9 pp22.1%52,097
Seat Atecaโˆ’4.6 pp12.2%51,705
Peugeot 108โˆ’4.5 pp18.7%77,108
Smart Fortwoโˆ’4.4 pp25.3%36,185
Mercedes-Benz C-Classโˆ’4.3 pp22.4%291,058
Toyota Aurisโˆ’4.3 pp25.1%119,161
Toyota Avensisโˆ’4.3 pp28.5%29,574
Mazda CX-3โˆ’4.3 pp16.5%25,277
Mercedes-Benz GLCโˆ’4.2 pp13.7%84,110
BMW 1 Seriesโˆ’4.1 pp21.9%343,724
Ford Pumaโˆ’4.1 pp8.5%89,711
Skoda Karoqโˆ’4.1 pp11.1%60,668
Mazda CX-30โˆ’4.1 pp8.7%20,642
Suzuki Vitaraโˆ’4.1 pp15.0%70,400
Skoda Yetiโˆ’4.1 pp26.1%74,268
Volvo XC40โˆ’4.0 pp10.0%88,007
Toyota Aygoโˆ’3.9 pp20.7%230,511
Toyota Yarisโˆ’3.9 pp21.3%328,202
Volvo XC60โˆ’3.9 pp19.5%115,821
Volkswagen Tiguanโˆ’3.9 pp17.8%245,388
BMW 2 Seriesโˆ’3.7 pp16.3%134,863
Jaguar Eโˆ’3.6 pp12.6%32,436
Honda Civicโˆ’3.6 pp24.5%152,003
Mercedes-Benz B-Classโˆ’3.5 pp24.4%59,760
Jaguar XEโˆ’3.5 pp19.0%42,897
Audi A4โˆ’3.2 pp23.5%177,810
Skoda Octaviaโˆ’3.2 pp21.7%174,759
Toyota Corollaโˆ’3.1 pp10.5%74,693
Skoda Kodiaqโˆ’3.1 pp12.8%43,952
Jaguar F-Paceโˆ’3.1 pp14.9%58,484
Volvo XC90โˆ’2.9 pp20.3%61,723
Kia Stonicโˆ’2.9 pp12.3%32,469
Mercedes-Benz GLAโˆ’2.8 pp16.7%91,753
Volkswagen Passatโˆ’2.8 pp25.5%138,295
Suzuki Ignisโˆ’2.8 pp14.2%26,235
Volkswagen Sharanโˆ’2.7 pp22.0%31,984
Volkswagen Touranโˆ’2.5 pp26.9%48,034
Ford Kugaโˆ’2.4 pp20.1%302,133
Toyota Versoโˆ’2.3 pp29.7%25,081
Mini Clubmanโˆ’2.2 pp20.4%25,982
Hyundai Ioniqโˆ’2.2 pp13.1%57,075
Volkswagen T-Crossโˆ’2.2 pp11.4%30,829
Peugeot 107โˆ’2.1 pp34.6%67,172
Suzuki SX4โˆ’2.1 pp24.4%35,889
Volvo V60โˆ’2.0 pp22.7%40,654
Mitsubishi Asxโˆ’2.0 pp25.5%28,733
Suzuki Swiftโˆ’1.9 pp23.5%111,357
Citroen C1โˆ’1.9 pp27.6%132,207
Land Rover Discovery Sportโˆ’1.9 pp19.0%110,042
Ford Mondeoโˆ’1.9 pp28.2%121,797
Toyota C-HRโˆ’1.7 pp14.1%102,173
Mazda CX-5โˆ’1.7 pp19.6%72,360
Volkswagen Sciroccoโˆ’1.7 pp30.5%39,502
Skoda Kamiqโˆ’1.6 pp11.2%23,994
Seat Alhambraโˆ’1.6 pp23.7%24,075
Seat Leonโˆ’1.5 pp22.6%166,783
Kia Niroโˆ’1.5 pp12.6%98,931
Vauxhall Vivaโˆ’1.5 pp21.4%38,090
Volkswagen ID.3โˆ’1.5 pp11.0%25,653
BMW X2โˆ’1.5 pp14.0%21,222
Mercedes-Benz A-Classโˆ’1.4 pp20.0%338,191
Skoda Fabiaโˆ’1.4 pp24.8%179,129
Ford C-Maxโˆ’1.3 pp29.4%88,829
Skoda Superbโˆ’1.3 pp22.2%63,225
Audi A1โˆ’1.2 pp23.8%234,825
Hyundai i10โˆ’1.2 pp26.0%227,851
Hyundai Tucsonโˆ’1.1 pp16.5%163,238
Land Rover Range Rover Velarโˆ’1.1 pp15.9%32,146
Mazda 2โˆ’1.0 pp26.7%104,207
Nissan Noteโˆ’1.0 pp31.9%100,984
Mitsubishi Outlanderโˆ’0.9 pp22.7%71,994
Kia Soulโˆ’0.9 pp27.9%22,853
Vauxhall Grandland Xโˆ’0.6 pp13.2%31,963
Suzuki Altoโˆ’0.6 pp34.0%38,416
Hyundai i20โˆ’0.5 pp26.4%124,258
Kia Xceedโˆ’0.5 pp12.3%24,594
Kia Vengaโˆ’0.3 pp29.0%46,359
MG HSโˆ’0.2 pp11.9%30,314
Citroen C3 Aircrossโˆ’0.2 pp15.4%35,536
Hyundai Konaโˆ’0.2 pp13.8%61,500
Ford KA+0.2 pp30.9%139,685
Mazda 6+0.2 pp28.1%47,222
Mercedes-Benz CLA+0.3 pp19.3%75,518
Kia Picanto+0.3 pp25.8%165,534
Mazda 3+0.3 pp27.1%83,271
Skoda Rapid+0.5 pp27.4%21,479
Seat Arona+0.5 pp15.8%56,484
Kia Sportage+0.6 pp22.6%294,022
Kia Rio+0.7 pp28.2%91,074
Ford Focus+0.9 pp28.6%692,707
Vauxhall Astra+1.0 pp30.7%443,645
Kia Sorento+1.1 pp25.9%31,088
Vauxhall Meriva+1.3 pp34.8%63,012
Vauxhall Crossland+1.3 pp16.4%62,301
Nissan Leaf+1.3 pp19.8%52,897
Fiat Panda+1.3 pp31.8%59,430
Hyundai ix20+1.6 pp30.8%28,751
Volvo V40+1.8 pp27.8%94,568
Hyundai Santa FE+1.8 pp29.8%28,666
Volkswagen Polo+1.9 pp28.3%502,172
Vauxhall Grandland+2.1 pp18.7%42,531
Renault Captur+2.1 pp24.0%162,092
Ford B-Max+2.3 pp32.1%53,635
Ford S-Max+2.3 pp32.9%55,308
Tesla Model 3+2.3 pp15.6%86,639
Volkswagen Beetle+2.4 pp33.7%20,951
Nissan Micra+2.4 pp30.2%137,308
Vauxhall Insignia+2.7 pp32.3%174,355
Alfa Romeo Giulietta+2.9 pp34.5%24,485
Hyundai ix35+3.0 pp36.2%49,770
Nissan X-Trail+3.5 pp27.0%72,495
Kia Ceed+3.5 pp30.0%110,450
Smart Forfour+3.6 pp26.8%21,160
Ford Ecosport+3.6 pp22.9%110,902
Vauxhall Zafira+3.6 pp35.6%132,650
Ford Fiesta+3.7 pp31.4%1,086,255
Fiat 500+3.7 pp31.1%315,134
MG ZS+3.9 pp17.6%60,555
Nissan Pulsar+4.0 pp29.3%20,791
Nissan Qashqai+4.4 pp29.4%560,260
Hyundai i30+4.6 pp34.0%91,640
Nissan Juke+4.7 pp30.3%326,524
Ford Galaxy+4.7 pp32.6%42,437
Tesla Model Y+4.7 pp16.2%32,476
Fiat 500X+4.9 pp27.3%36,657
Renault Zoe+5.1 pp21.4%26,996
Jeep Renegade+5.2 pp27.5%29,281
Peugeot 3008+5.2 pp28.7%143,194
Peugeot 208+5.2 pp29.6%218,868
Citroen C3+5.3 pp32.4%160,565
Peugeot 2008+5.4 pp26.0%144,569
Ford Grand C-Max+5.4 pp34.8%34,570
Seat Ibiza+5.5 pp32.3%169,193
Peugeot 308+5.6 pp33.7%110,832
Renault Kadjar+5.9 pp26.4%69,279
MG 3+5.9 pp25.1%24,672
Vauxhall Corsa+6.5 pp33.2%750,609
Peugeot 5008+7.5 pp28.7%36,977
Vauxhall Adam+7.8 pp34.3%58,720
Renault Scenic+7.8 pp41.8%22,971
Vauxhall Mokka+7.9 pp30.9%252,616
Fiat Punto+8.2 pp42.9%29,424
Dacia Duster+9.3 pp29.0%81,404
Dacia Sandero+9.5 pp31.0%117,357
Peugeot 207+9.9 pp48.7%57,709
Citroen C4+10.0 pp38.2%114,334
Citroen C4 Cactus+10.2 pp30.2%21,184
Renault Megane+11.1 pp43.3%68,969
DS Ds3+11.4 pp34.1%33,856
Renault Clio+13.0 pp40.2%227,245
Citroen DS3+14.1 pp48.2%68,131

Source: DVSA anonymised MOT tests (OGL v3.0)

How we calculated this

Why adjust for age? Older cars fail far more often, so a raw failure rate would simply favour newer models. Each model is therefore compared only with cars from the same year, weighted by the number of tests.

The 15 best and 15 worst models. Cars aged 3โ€“15 (first used 2010โ€“2022), at least 50 tests per year. Van models are left out.

WhatsAppFacebookX

Read next

Check how rare your car is and compare your mileage โ†’

Cite this page

You may use the figures and charts freely with a credit and a link to this page.

Source: RareCar (DVLA/DVSA data), 31 Dec 2025. https://rarecar.eu/uk/articles/most-reliable-cars-mot/

Download share image

Terms and open data