How rare is your car? Built on open registration data

Porsche did best at the MOT, Dacia worst

Porsche cars failed their 2025 MOT less than half as often as cars of the same age: 9.1%, against about 22%. Dacia did worst (30% vs about 21%). The comparison covers 32 brands with at least 50,000 tests.

RareCar · Published 17 Nov 2026 · 2 min read
Source: DVSA anonymised MOT tests (OGL v3.0)

Porsche Macan
Porsche Macan. Photo: Vauxford · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons
of Dacia tests failed
30%
same-age cars 21%
of Porsche tests failed
9.1%
same-age cars 22%

Top five

  1. 1Porschesame-age cars 22% · 125,188 tests9.1%
  2. 2Lexussame-age cars 23% · 132,564 tests12%
  3. 3Hondasame-age cars 27% · 579,674 tests19%
  4. 4Minisame-age cars 22% · 560,123 tests16%
  5. 5Jaguarsame-age cars 23% · 272,433 tests18%

Bottom five

  1. 1Daciasame-age cars 21% · 216,526 tests30%
  2. 2Renaultsame-age cars 26% · 634,494 tests34%
  3. 3Citroensame-age cars 27% · 606,198 tests33%
  4. 4Vauxhallsame-age cars 27% · 2,110,308 tests31%
  5. 5Peugeotsame-age cars 26% · 917,458 tests30%

Porsche, Lexus, Honda lead. 13 of the 32 brands are within three percentage points of the average for cars of the same age, so for most brands the differences are small.

Adjusting for age changes the order. On raw failure rate alone Tesla would rank 3, but compared with cars of the same age it ranks 23. Brands have fleets of different ages, and raw figures favour brands whose cars are newer on average.

Porsche and Lexus fail least often, Dacia most often

Cars aged 3–15, MOT tests in 2025. All car models of the brand combined; van models left out.

← fails less oftenfails more often →
Porsche · 125,188 tests
−13.0 pp
Lexus · 132,564 tests
−10.9 pp
Honda · 579,674 tests
−8.0 pp
Mini · 560,123 tests
−5.9 pp
Jaguar · 272,433 tests
−5.6 pp
Land Rover · 677,875 tests
−5.5 pp
BMW · 1,571,399 tests
−5.5 pp
Audi · 1,521,752 tests
−5.3 pp
Toyota · 1,215,836 tests
−4.5 pp
Mercedes-Benz · 1,341,551 tests
−3.5 pp
Volkswagen · 2,084,582 tests
−3.1 pp
Suzuki · 349,477 tests
−2.7 pp
Skoda · 724,649 tests
−2.6 pp
Volvo · 495,374 tests
−2.3 pp
Mazda · 406,049 tests
−2.0 pp
Mitsubishi · 146,538 tests
−1.8 pp
Smart · 57,563 tests
−1.5 pp
Hyundai · 868,842 tests
+0.2 pp
Kia · 955,969 tests
+0.5 pp
Seat · 510,049 tests
+0.8 pp
Ford · 2,863,773 tests
+1.4 pp
Alfa Romeo · 52,482 tests
+1.7 pp
Tesla · 136,166 tests
+2.6 pp
Jeep · 59,777 tests
+2.7 pp
MG · 137,436 tests
+3.3 pp
Nissan · 1,295,047 tests
+3.5 pp
Fiat · 516,704 tests
+3.8 pp
Peugeot · 917,458 tests
+4.1 pp
Vauxhall · 2,110,308 tests
+4.3 pp
Citroen · 606,198 tests
+5.6 pp
Renault · 634,494 tests
+8.1 pp
Dacia · 216,526 tests
+9.3 pp
Show as table
BrandDifference vs same ageFailure rate 3–15 yrsFailure rate allTests
Porsche−13.0 pp9.1%12.5%125,188
Lexus−10.9 pp12.4%16.1%132,564
Honda−8.0 pp19.2%27.6%579,674
Mini−5.9 pp16.0%16.3%560,123
Jaguar−5.6 pp17.5%20.6%272,433
Land Rover−5.5 pp19.4%23.2%677,875
BMW−5.5 pp18.6%20.7%1,571,399
Audi−5.3 pp19.3%21.5%1,521,752
Toyota−4.5 pp19.6%24.6%1,215,836
Mercedes-Benz−3.5 pp19.9%22.1%1,341,551
Volkswagen−3.1 pp22.1%26.2%2,084,582
Suzuki−2.7 pp22.2%26.4%349,477
Skoda−2.6 pp21.3%23.6%724,649
Volvo−2.3 pp21.2%24.6%495,374
Mazda−2.0 pp23.2%27.1%406,049
Mitsubishi−1.8 pp23.4%27.7%146,538
Smart−1.5 pp25.9%29.4%57,563
Hyundai+0.2 pp24.4%26.1%868,842
Kia+0.5 pp23.5%24.8%955,969
Seat+0.8 pp24.3%26.1%510,049
Ford+1.4 pp28.2%31.2%2,863,773
Alfa Romeo+1.7 pp30.6%32.2%52,482
Tesla+2.6 pp16.4%16.1%136,166
Jeep+2.7 pp25.6%27.4%59,777
MG+3.3 pp17.9%19.2%137,436
Nissan+3.5 pp29.4%31.9%1,295,047
Fiat+3.8 pp31.1%33.1%516,704
Peugeot+4.1 pp29.9%32.9%917,458
Vauxhall+4.3 pp31.2%33.6%2,110,308
Citroen+5.6 pp32.7%35.0%606,198
Renault+8.1 pp33.7%36.6%634,494
Dacia+9.3 pp30.1%30.0%216,526

Source: DVSA anonymised MOT tests (OGL v3.0)

How we calculated this

Why adjust for age? Older cars fail far more often, so a raw failure rate would simply favour newer models. Each model is therefore compared only with cars from the same year, weighted by the number of tests.

Read next

Check how rare your car is and compare your mileage →